Inigo, the sea lion, is hurt that his friend, Pecas, shows something he was hiding in his flipper to another sea lion, Poppy, but not to him. In fact, he is so upset, he wants to get even with Pecas by hurting him back. His mom plays a game with him to explore the idea that sometimes things aren't what they seem. Will playing the gane help Inigo move on in time for Inigo's birthday party, even though he still doesn't know what Pecas had in his flipper? Frolic along with the sea lions to find out the surprise that explains What Could Be Going On!